There has been some talk in the Twins' camp of playing Jacque Jones at first base. Gardenhire had this to say about the notion:
I'm not afraid to do that at all. If we don't have Morneau, and four outfielders all swinging good ... you try to find a way to get them all in.
A simple enough idea. You have a guy who is hurt and his empty spot coupled with the fact you have 4 guys who are playing pretty well but not enough spots for them. My question is "Why Jacque?" Between Jacque Jones, Lew Ford, Shannon Stewart, and Torii Hunter, why has Gardenhire chosen Jones over the others? And why not use the real infielders?
Torii Hunter
Torii is the tallest of the group, listed at 6'2". This would give the infielders the biggest target. And you know Torii will catch it if it's anywhere near him. But that sentiment is exactly why Hunter will never be at first. His defensive abilities are far too valuable to be taken out of centerfield. Plus he's right-handed, making it just a little harder to field balls between the bases and to hold the runner.
Lew FordFor starters, Lew is next tallest at 6'0". Lew is usually the everyday DH, but that rule will not be in effect during play at the National League park. It would seem simpler just to move him from DH to 1B and leave the outfield as it was, using Michael Ryan to give guys days off. However, I think Lew's defensive abilities put him above the other two for outfield work. And again, right-handed. Moving on.
Shannon StewartShannon might not always get to the ball, but he has pretty good hands once he does. While by no means slow, he is, in my opinion, he is the slowest of the four. I have, in the past, advocated the position swap of Lew and Shannon, but I'm not so sure anymore after that "throw" home by Lew in Cleveland. Still, less territory to cover may be a good move. Added to this equation is the injured calf sustained from a self-inflicted foul ball that kept him out of Sunday's game. Does Shannon have the range of motion needed for outfield work? Shannon is listed at 5'11", a full 5 inches shorter than Justin Morneau. Will the infielder's be comfortable with the smaller target?
Jacque Jones Jones is the only left-handed fielder in the group, which is generally a good thing for first base work.
TANGENT ALERT: In middle school, I almost lost my job to a kid
the class behind me because he was left-handed and could get more balls to his
right. Never mind that's all he could do better. I could jump higher, get balls
in the dirt better and had better range on popups. Coach ended up seeing the
folly of his ways and kept me there. In the end, I ended up in rightfield anyway
because our first baseman was built in the mold of a Hispanic Mo Vaughn. Coach
wanted both of us in the lineup, but someone had to play right and it wasn't
going to be Escobar.
Anyway...Jacque, right. Being at first means he's closer to everyone he may have to throw a ball to. This is actually worse on the air-mailed throws, because the ball will still be going up when it goes over someone's head. But on those throws he four-hops to the plate from left will actually hit Mauer on the fly now, or at least only one hop.
Between the infielders, we have LeCroy, Cuddyer, and this new Williams guy. Why didn't anyone tell me the organization called this guy up? I don't know if he has 1B abilities, but he's gotta be better than Tiffee. I wanted to strangle Tiffee after he missed that catch. Who can't catch a shin-high throw? Das vidania, Terry. Otherwise, it's LeCroy or Cuddyer. Cuddyer could play first, and according to his bio page, Williams plays third. LeCroy could play first, keeping Cuddyer at third. I'm not comfortable with the idea of LeCroy being over there either. This leaves us with Stewart, Jones, Cuddyer, and possibly Williams. For simplicity's sake, I'm going to assume this guy can't field a lick of firstbase, not that that's stopped Gardy before. We're talking about Jacque over there in the first place, not to mention the Terry Tiffee Experiment.
Do the Twins go with Cuddyer, Stewart, or Jones? My first instinct would be to say Cuddyer. He is an infielder with 146 innings played at first, slightly more than 16 whole games. Neither of the other two have any career experience in the infield. If Williams is not up to the task of playing third, necessity dictates that Cuddyer stay there, leaving Stewart or Jones. Of these two, who do you go with? I think either choice is equally foolish, and yet I'm ok with the idea of either of them playing there. Maybe I'm still so appalled at the collective showing of Tiffee and LeCroy that I'm willing to put up with anything. The call comes down to Stewart's range versus Jones' arm. In the end, I think Jacque is actually the right pick for the job. As odd as this feels to say it, I think Jacque Jones could actually be a fairly effective first baseman. I don't think he'll ever be as good as a regular, but he doesn't have to be. The Twins have 6 NL park games coming up. If all 4 outfielders stay hot at the plate, look for them all to be in the field too.